Alfie joined Wanderers after a brief spell at Boreham Wood in September 2022. A graduate of the AFC Wimbledon academy back in 2016, Alfie made his first team debut for the club later that year in the EFL Trophy against Plymouth Argyle. Gaining further experience with loan spells at Sutton United, East Thurrock United and Kingstonian, Alfie left Wimbledon in 2019 and signed for Ebbsfleet United after a successful trial. A key player for the Kent outfit, Alfie also enjoyed a decent stint with National League Premier side Maidenhead United on loan in 2020.